The Death of Jim O'Brien
December 17, 2004 Recent editorial comment in the
Bridgeton News, my local newspaper, along with letters and emails to the
editor of the paper dealing with the death of television personality Jim
O'Brien, has prompted me to write this essay. Although Mr. O'Brien died over
21 years ago, his death is often a topic of conversation when the subject of
skydiving is discussed locally. The public's love of Jim is understandable
but the information provided by readers has been incorrect, incomplete and
confusing to non-jumpers.
Jim O'Brien achieved media-star
status in the Delaware Valley area because of his wonderful sense of humor
and strong personality. Jim was the weatherman folks turned to both
for the weather as well as nightly entertainment. His love of parachuting
was often a topic of comment during his weather reporting. His death was a
huge loss to the sport of parachuting. I know very few people who did as
much for the sport as he did.
After reading a number of comments in the
Bridgeton News which I knew to be incorrect, I decided to investigate the
issue by calling friends and ex-students of mine who jumped regularly at the
drop zone in Pennsylvania where Jim died. I also used Google.com to find
online information. Much to my surprise, the online references were just as
wrong as the comments in the newspaper. It became obvious to me that most of
the letter writers got their information from the Internet. What follows
represents what I have discovered regarding Jim's untimely death.
Jim O'Brien died in late September, 1983.
None of my jumper friends could state the exact date and neither could I,
although I remember exactly what I was doing that day; much like I remember
when I heard of President Kennedy's death and, of course, the World Trade
Center attacks. The date appears online as the 23rd and the 25th. One
jumper has posted to a parachuting website that the date was the 23rd. I
don't know which is correct.
As to the place of Jim's death, it was at
United Parachute Club drop zone in Pennsylvania. The New Hanover airport was
sold a few years ago to a developer of shopping malls. The United Club is
one of the oldest in the country. I jumped at United in many parachute
competitions during the late 1960s and early 1970s. I always enjoyed flying jumpers
there often in
my Cessna 182 after getting out of the drop zone ownership business. Most of the
United club
members, some ex-students of mine, have more than 6000 jumps.
All of the jumpers I've talked to, two who
were actually there that fateful day, and many who heard the details from
others who were there, pretty much agree on all the details which I will attempt to
explain. My explanation requires background for non-jumpers; I
apologize to those jumpers who happen upon this page.
Readers knowledgeable about ram air parachutes and
parachute control or those who bore easily with excessive technical
detail can skim the following section and jump ahead to the section which
begins "...back to Jim's jump."
Jim O'Brien had about 600 parachute jumps.
Not a terribly large number but he was certainly not a beginner. He was
jumping a parachute which is known by jumpers as 'a square' although its
shape is actually rectangular. The more technical name for the canopy is a
ram air foil from the action of air being forced into it.
The canopy is airfoil shaped with multiple
individual cells with openings into the cells along the leading edge of the
airfoil. The canopy has a distinct curved upper surface and a lower surface
to which lines are attached in such a way to create an
airfoil with lift like an airplane wing. The leading edge of the airfoil is
open and the trailing edge is closed.
During the opening sequence, air is rammed
into the open leading edge. The force of air into the cell is much like what
happens when a paper bag is filled with air. All the air cells fill quickly
and the nylon material forms the shape of a wing. The air which is forced
into the leading edge opening keeps the airfoil wing open above the jumper.
As gravity pulls the jumper down the angle of the wing relative to the wind
keeps the cells filled with air and the jumper glides to earth under the
open canopy.
The parachute canopy is steer able with
control lines which are attached to the outside cells at the trailing edge
of the wing. The control lines extend downward from the trailing edge to a
line keeper on the riser assemble which connects the jumper's harness to the
suspension lines. The jumper reaches up to grab the control lines just after
the inflation of the air foil wing. The canopy is steered by pulling down
either the right or left control line to turn in that direction. Pulling down
the control line severely distorts the trailing edge on the side pulled down. The
wing distortion on the pulled side creates a significant drag on the pulled
side and the other side of the canopy, which is not pulled down, moves
forward and causes the jumper and wing assembly to rotate roughly along the
vertical axis of the jumper and the canopy. Thus, pulling down a control
toggle distorts the trailing edge on that side and the non-impeded airflow
on the opposite side causes the turn.
The action of pulling down a toggle to turn
for an extended length of time causes the canopy and jumper to turn in the
direction of the toggle pull but also to begin an outward swing of the
jumper's body away from the vertical. The farther down a control toggle is pulled,
and the longer it is held down, the great is the swinging of the jumper's
body away from the vertical. If the toggle is held down as far as possible, which
is downward as far as the jumper can reach, for more than a few seconds the
jumper's body begins to swing out of the vertical plane and the body moves
toward the horizontal. With a sustained toggle pull in one direction the
jumper's body begins an outward motion away out from the vertical and, with
continual line extension, the jumpers becomes almost horizontal as well as spinning
very fast downward.
The net effect of the actions I'm describing creates a
fast downward descent of the jumper in a movement which is very much like a
corkscrewing effect. Jumpers perform this extreme turn because it creates a
rapid loss of altitude...as well as providing a fun ride. Air show
skydivers, such as the Golden Knights, have multiple smoke grenades of
various colors, hanging on a line. As the jumper descends rapidly a
3-dimensional, multi-colored corkscrew of smoke. The visual effect is
stunning but the jumpers are disoriented by the spinning.
One of the effects of the turn as described
is that the jumper's perception of the ground is displaced: it is now viewed
at his side and spinning excessively...rather than downward beyond his feet. Similarly,
if the jumper
is getting close to the ground he is probably looking for a landing spot as
well as determining the wind velocity so he can create a landing approach
into the wind. Ram air parachutes are almost always landed into the wind so
that the forward drive, or movement, of the parachute is somewhat countered
by the wind. Therefore, the jumper can control the landing such that a
landing standing up is done regularly.
Back to Jim's jump.
Jim and a friend,
Doug Sellick, both had perfectly good, fully operational canopies. Both of
their canopies were fully open and neither jumper had any difficulty
controlling their parachute. Both jumpers began the corkscrew maneuver
described above in order to descend quickly. Many jumpers make 8-10
jumps a day and getting to the ground quickly means getting back into the
air quickly. The spiraling, corkscrew is a very common thing to do to
descend rapidly.
Unfortunately, in this case, either or both
of the jumpers lost awareness of where the other guy was and they entangled
with one another. The centrifugal force of the spiraling caused their
parachutes to wrap around one another and collapse. One canopy completely and
one partially. All accounts indicate that this took place at about 600 feet.
(Most jumpers open at an altitude of 1500 to 2000 feet regardless of the
altitude from which they exited the airplane.) Therefore, Jim and Doug had
perfectly good, functioning canopies for most of their descent under canopy.
After the entanglement, which was noticed
from the ground after the two guys were yelling at each other about what to
do about their predicament. For what ever reason, Jim elected to do a
cutaway. A cutaway is the disconnecting of the canopy assembly from the
jumper's harness by the pulling of a ripcord for that specific purpose. The
cutaway procedure is taught and practiced repeatedly during a jumper's
progression through the various stages of learning the details of jumping.
Needless to say, knowing how close one is to
the ground is of critical importance to a jumper. Altitude awareness... and
constant vigilance in regard to it... is one of the most important things any
jumper learns. But the act of colliding with another in the air and getting
tangled up in each other's equipment could certainly take one's mind off the
issue of altitude for some period of time. After Jim's cutaway he waited a
few seconds before pulling the reserve ripcord. The reserve parachute opened
immediately after his pull and was observed by many on the ground.
As a parachute deploys, the lines and canopy
come out of the container as the lines begin to stretch out. Ideally, the
canopy catches air and slows the falling jumper to the safe speed of the
deployed reserve canopy. Unfortunately, in Jim's case, he impacted the
ground before the reserve parachute was fully inflated.
The other jumper involved in the collision was able
to get the entangled mess he had over his head opened enough to land without
having to pull his reserve.
One jumper who jumped at United on a regular
basis, told me that he had heard that Jim had nylon cord burns on his neck.
The speculation at the time was that he was badly scrapped by the cords
after his cutaway and the burns may have distracted him from the immediate issue of
pulling the reserve rip cord. Again, this is speculation to explain the
delay from cutaway to reserve pull. A jumper with 600 or more jumps would
not wait long to pull his reserve without some reason.
Essentially, his delay before pulling his reserve--what ever
the reason for the delay--is
what contributed most to his death.
Some additional information and comments
about this incident. Jim was not making a tandem jump. Meaning, he was not
connected to another jumper with them both intending to land on the same,
but much larger, parachute. Tandem jumps, with an experienced tandem master, is
the way most people have been introduced to the sport over the last 15 or 20
years. Internet accounts incorrectly state that Jim was jumping tandem with
a woman. In fact, tandem jumping was not done experimentally until the same
year he died.
Various accounts in our local newspaper
indicates that Jim jumped in the Bridgeton area. This is true. One of his
instructor/jumpmasters was negotiating to purchase the crop dusting strip
owned by Al LiCalzi. Both Jim and I spoke at various meetings in
Bridgeton in favor of the facility in hopes that a drop zone could be opened
there. I don't think Jim's death had any influence on the deal not going
through. If I remember correctly, the issues were related to the price of
the land and the amount of land they could use for the drop zone.
In my research for this essay I found an
interesting piece of trivia regarding Jim's family. His daughter, Peri
Gilpin, plays "Roz Doyle" on the NBC sitcom, "Frasier".
This essay was written in an attempt to bring
some facts forward regarding the circumstances of Jim O'Brien's death.
And to say, "You can't always believe what
you read on the Internet."
Links to some sources used in this article are:
http://www.nj.com/printer/printer.ssf?/base/news-10/1102674018112440.xml
http://www.famous56.com/jim/
http://www.dropzone.com/cgi-bin/forum/gforum.cgi?post=1257116;search_string=Jim%20o%27brien;#1257116
http://www.angelfire.com/celeb/JLeeves/periin.htm
Author's Experience
By way of background, I submit the
following information to give credence to my comments. I made my
first military parachute jump in 1960 with jump school class 6-60 while
serving with the 82nd Airborne Division at Ft. Bragg, NC. I made my first
sport parachute jump in June of 1960 while a member of the XVIII Airborne
Corps Sport Parachute Club. I became licensed as a Jumpmaster and an
Instructor by the United States Parachute Association in 1972. I owned two
parachute schools in New Jersey and one in Pennsylvania. I hold an FAA
Commercial Pilots license and have 1500+ hours flying skydivers. I hold an
FAA senior rigger license with chest and back certifications.
I also hold
the world parachute record for getting sick while jumping out of an airplane
at night. My whimsical account of that record attempt can be seen
HERE.
Because of the many jumps I've made in
Cumberland County--at my drop zone, various fire company picnics and at the Cumberland County
Fairgrounds--I have been asked often if I was Jim O'Brien's instructor. I
was not his instructor. I did make a few jumps with him--and a plane load of
20 other people--out of a DC-3.
Although I was not Jim O'Brien's instructor,
I did teach a number of Cumberland County residents how to jump. I taught a
course at the County College many years ago which had Tia Riviera, Lee
Bonham, Anita Rokulis and Diane Beatty in the class. There were a number of
others whose name escape me after 30 years! Although not in the
college class, I also taught Cumberland County Freeholder Bruce Peterson and
his brother, Greg, for their first jump. I taught retired Bridgeton Chief of
Police John Bondi for his first jump. I taught John Cooper, son of long-time
Bridgeton News photographer Gary Cooper.
The first two jumps made at my drop
zone in Woodbine were made by Paul Merkoski, the current editor of The Press
of Atlantic City, when he was just a reporter, and another reporter, Drew Strunk.
If you have comments or question regarding this
document send mail to me HERE.
|